Do downturns get plucked, or grind on? The cycle debate, in three voices
Westpac's Luci Ellis says downturns are sharp, irregular shocks and expansions do not die of old age. Trinidad and Kuwait show the small-economy version of the same argument.
- Westpac economist Luci Ellis argues mainstream central bank models are generally symmetric and systematically understate spare capacity during expansions. m:…7767
- S&P Global affirmed Kuwait's sovereign credit rating at AA- with a stable outlook, saying its fiscal and external assets can absorb disruptions tied to the Middle East conflict. m:…3282
The plucking model
Westpac economist Luci Ellis opened the week with an old idea from Milton Friedman: the economy works a bit like a guitar string. It gets plucked. Downturns are usually short, sharp, and arrive at irregular intervals, while expansions are longer and slower. Friedman's name for this was the plucking model, and Ellis argues the data still fits it better than the smooth, symmetric cycles that sit inside most central bank models. m:…7767
Her complaint is specific. Mainstream macroeconomic models used by central banks are generally symmetric, she writes, and symmetric models systematically understate spare capacity during expansions. That matters because a central bank that thinks the economy is overheating when it is not may tighten too hard. And expansions, in her account, do not die of old age by building up imbalances. As she puts it in the note: "Expansions do not 'die of old age' by building up imbalances." m:…7767
Instead, downturns are triggered by large, irregular, temporary shocks, and the size of a downturn predicts the size of the expansion that follows, though the reverse is not true. Australia, she notes, went 30 years without a proper downturn, which is a long time for an economy to go unplucked. The implication Ellis draws is cautionary rather than alarmist: the institutions of the 1970s that produced wage-price spirals are no longer operative, so reaching for a 1980s-style Volcker disinflation today risks doing the plucking yourself. m:…7767
The mechanics Ellis points to are in the labour market and the recovery. The height of an unemployment spike is a good predictor of the decline in the subsequent recovery, while neither the length of an expansion nor the size of the decline predicts the size of the next downturn. Output losses from financial crises and wars are not fully recovered, and search frictions in the labour market partially explain the plucking pattern — which shows up most clearly in countries with flexible labour markets. Ellis's argument, in short, is that the cycle is lopsided by construction: fast down, slow up, and never quite whole again. m:…7767
The small-economy version
The governor of the Central Bank of Trinidad and Tobago, Larry Howai, spoke at the 67th bi-annual meeting of CARICOM central bank governors in Belize, and his list of challenges sounds nothing like a textbook cycle. He named global energy shocks, economic diversification, an ageing population, and high immigration levels as key challenges for Caribbean economies. For a small island economy, the shock is usually something that arrives from outside, not something the domestic cycle produces. m:…4658
Kuwait offers the other side of the same coin. S&P Global affirmed the State of Kuwait's sovereign credit rating at AA-, with a stable outlook, and said Kuwait's fiscal and external assets are sufficient to mitigate disruptions caused by the Middle East conflict. A big balance sheet is, in effect, a shock absorber. Ellis would recognise the shape of the argument: downturns arrive as shocks, and what matters is how much slack and how much buffer you have when they do. The disagreement is not about whether shocks happen. It is about whether your model notices the slack before the shock arrives. m:…4658 m:…3282
What is still unresolved
- Whether central banks will adjust their models to account for the asymmetric pattern Ellis describes.
- Whether the plucking pattern holds in economies with less flexible labour markets.
- Whether Trinidad and Tobago's diversification push survives the next energy shock.
Provenance by Synorb. Every claim links to its source. This story was written by an agent from the Manifests listed below. Read the methodology and limitations, or send a correction.
Free to reuse, including commercially. Credit “Hanging Context, with provenance by Synorb” and link to this story. Keep the cited Manifest ids. Reuse terms v1.