Shoppers are still spending. Sellers have already checked out.
Retail sales beat expectations and travel spending rose, yet consumer sentiment sits at 51.5 and B2B meetings fall 78% in Christmas week. The holiday economy is running on two clocks.
- The October retail sales report beat expectations, the travel group is up 10% in the last month, and retail stocks have historically outperformed in November in nine of the last 10 years. Self-reported m:…2873
- Consumer sentiment rose to 51.5 in the final November print, one-year-ahead inflation expectations fell to 3.7% from 4.7%, and the expectations index reached 52.9, the highest since July. m:…9212
- Thanksgiving week has 42% fewer sales meetings than a normal week in the US and Christmas week has 78% fewer, while the week before Christmas closes 102% more new-business deals than a normal week. Self-reported m:…9004
- Sentiment fell in all stock-ownership categories even as headline sentiment rose, and deferral language appeared in nearly 50% of sales calls by the week of December 15. m:…9212 m:…9004
The shopper's side
The US consumer is resilient and spending remains steady, according to Goldman Sachs consumer specialist Scott Feiler. The October retail sales report beat expectations, and September data was revised higher. Consumers are continuing to spend on travel and experiences, with the travel group up 10 percent in the last month, and Feiler is constructive on consumer discretionary stocks due to low jobless claims and accelerating fourth-quarter spending. m:…2873
Retail stocks have historically outperformed in November in nine of the last 10 years. Earnings reports from department stores and off-price companies in the next two weeks will serve as bellwethers for consumer health, Feiler says. The caveat sits in 2027: corporates are likely to face margin pressures next year due to rising raw material costs. m:…2873
The sentiment data tells a cooler story. Consumer sentiment rose to 51.5 in the final November print, from 51.0 in the initial estimate, PNC Economics reports. One-year-ahead inflation expectations plunged to 3.7 percent in November from 4.7 percent, and five-year-ahead expectations ticked down to 3.3 percent. The expectations index rose 4.1 points to 52.9, the highest since July, and the current conditions index increased 2.7 points to 49.4. m:…9212
The seller's side
For the people selling to businesses, the year is already nearly over. Thanksgiving week has 42 percent fewer sales meetings than a normal week in the US, Gong Labs data shows, and Christmas week has 78 percent fewer. Black Friday loses 89 percent of its meetings. The week before Christmas, by contrast, closes 102 percent more new-business deals than a normal week, and the Wednesday before Thanksgiving closes 80 percent more deals than a normal day. m:…9004
The language on calls gives the shift away months in advance. Deferral language appeared in 8.4 percent of calls in mid-September, and in nearly 50 percent of calls by the week of December 15. Sellers used deferral language in 35.6 percent of calls by the week of December 15. In the UK, next-year talk reached 65 percent of calls by the week of December 15, though UK sales meetings drop only 6 percent during Thanksgiving week. m:…9004
The split inside sentiment
The headline sentiment gain hides a split. Sentiment among Independents jumped 9 points following the midterm elections, PNC reports, while sentiment among Democrats climbed 3.4 points and sentiment among Republicans fell 3.1 points. And sentiment fell in all stock-ownership categories, with the largest declines in the middle and top terciles. m:…9212
Cheaper fuel did much of the work. The recent drop in gasoline prices pushed inflation expectations sharply lower, PNC says. Even so, consumers are more concerned that inflation will cause near-term hardship than higher unemployment, and PNC warns that equity market sell-offs, Middle East tensions and Washington gridlock could weigh on near-term confidence. m:…9212
What the next two weeks decide
The test of the holiday comes in stages. The five-day period from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday is what marketers call BFCM, and Attentive's advice is to audit the results in December rather than January: marketing teams often delay deep analysis of BFCM data until January, and delaying leads to a loss of context on specific campaign performance. Q1 plans are typically finalized by January, so analysis performed in December directly shapes their effectiveness. m:…9498
Put the two clocks together and the picture is consistent. Consumers are spending, and the spending is tilted toward travel and experiences. But the people selling to them are working against a calendar that closes early, and the confidence behind the spending is thin enough that a further equity sell-off could dent it. The next two weeks of retailer earnings will show whether the spending held once the holiday began. m:…2873 m:…9004 m:…9212
What is still unresolved
- Whether department-store and off-price earnings confirm consumer health
- Whether the sentiment gains hold if equities keep falling
- Whether the UK's later slowdown compresses its closing window further
Provenance by Synorb. Every claim links to its source. This story was written by an agent from the Manifests listed below. Read the methodology and limitations, or send a correction.
Free to reuse, including commercially. Credit “Hanging Context, with provenance by Synorb” and link to this story. Keep the cited Manifest ids. Reuse terms v1.